What I Learned From Losing a School Board Race

This has been a year of firsts for Andrea and me. I can’t remember another year when so many new things happened at once:

  • In September I left full-time IT and cybersecurity work to focus entirely on my executive coaching practice.
  • Andrea, a middle school science teacher, plans to retire in June 2027.
  • Our first granddaughter (and second grandchild) was born in June, on my parents’ 63rd wedding anniversary.
  • Our grandson started preschool in August.
  • I ran for our town’s Board of Education and was on the November ballot.

Each of these deserves its own story, but this post is about the last one. I had never run a political campaign. I’ve voted in every election since I turned 18, but I don’t consider myself a political person.

Why I ran

It started with a tax bill. In 2024 we received a large tax increase, and I wanted to understand why, so I began attending Board of Education (BOE) meetings. I also filed a series of Open Public Records Act (OPRA) requests for budget, staffing, enrollment and curriculum data going back to 2018, and built a timeline of what had happened in our district.

What began as a budget exercise became something bigger. The data showed that many of our children needed significant help to reach grade level in reading, writing and math, and that Asbury Park trailed much of the state. Based on what I’d gathered, I became convinced we could substantially improve the quality of education, and spend less than we historically had to improve it.

Andrea was a huge help. She shared her own experience as a teacher and that of her peers, and she was a great sounding board for some of my more creative (and likely bad!) ideas. Working on it together was genuinely fun.

Running alone

In New Jersey, getting on the school board ballot takes a petition signed by at least 25 registered voters in town. I collected more than 30, just to be safe. A new friend who had been attending BOE meetings with me did the same. New Jersey allows candidates to run as a “slate,” but we agreed that board members should be independent thinkers, so the plan was to run alongside each other but independently.

We soon learned that a slate of three would also be running together: five candidates for three seats. BOE races here had been combative in recent years, and I committed to running a clean, positive campaign. My friend worried the race would turn nasty and withdrew a week after filing. That left four candidates for three seats, and me running entirely on my own.

The math of a campaign

My plan was simple: talk with as many people in person as I could, share what I’d learned over 15+ months of BOE meetings, and lay out my vision for the district.

I estimated it would take about 2,000 votes to be competitive, in a town of about 9,000 households. Through another OPRA request I got the list of everyone who voted in both 2022 and 2025, the last midterm and off-year elections, on the theory that they were very likely to vote again in 2026. That narrowed the list to about 4,000 households.

That’s still a lot of doors. I canvassed every day for more than two months and went to every local event I could. Friends knocked on some doors, but I did more than 80% of it myself. Even so, I spoke with just over 1,000 people. For the rest, I counted on social media, Nextdoor posts, radio interviews and three candidate forums, one of them live on Zoom.

It all got good coverage, but it wasn’t nearly enough. All three candidates on the slate won comfortably. It turns out running as a team matters: when voters don’t know the individual candidates, it’s easier to vote for a team.

Election night

About 30 of us gathered at a local brewery to wait for the results. When it became clear I wouldn’t win, the mood in the room changed instantly. Andrea said a few words, then I thanked everyone. It was far more emotional than I expected. I’m competitive, and losing is never easy.

But I was also exhilarated. I met so many new people, some of whom have become fast friends. I spent a lot of time on the southwest side of Asbury Park, meeting people I’d rarely cross paths with otherwise. They were smart, charming, passionate, and sometimes really angry about the school system. And I found where I want to give my time going forward: the children of Asbury Park.

What I learned

  • Teams win. However hard one person works, an organized team usually wins. That’s as true in business as it is in an election.
  • Learn one new thing and meet one new person every day. Someone taught me this early in my career, and I realized the campaign’s energy came from it. These two months put it into overdrive. I met dozens of new people every day and learned so much from our residents, especially those who lived here through the city’s lean times.
  • How you lose changes with time. Twenty or thirty years ago, I’d have been upset and called it wasted time. Today I’m still disappointed, but I gained far more than I lost. It’s an experience I’ll treasure, and one I won’t repeat! 🙂

Facing a setback of your own? Talking it through helps. Let’s talk.

Back to Blog